Sales
of commodities—what constitutes security
Effective
January 11, 1983, the Commodity Exchange Act was amended to afford the states
authority to take action, under the Blue Sky Laws or otherwise, against fraud in
the sale of commodities which do not occur on regulated exchanges.
Under the Securities Act of Arizona, the sales of certain commodities which do
not require delivery to the purchaser within 28 days of payment of any portion
of the purchase price are defined as securities.
The result of this provision is that such transactions are subject to the
regulatory provisions of the Arizona Securities Act. It is felt that the disclosure requirements and review
associated with registration will reduce investor losses as a result of fraud in
this area. Individuals engaging in
any form of deferred delivery transactions are invited to come in and discuss
registration and the law in this area.
[What
Constitutes Security]
In the meantime, the issue of what constitutes a security in other areas
continues to confront the Division. Sellers
seeking to avoid disclosure requirements under the Act continue to be creative
in putting together programs which, they argue, do not fall within the
definition of a security. The most
common tact is to utilize “third parties” to provide managerial efforts for
investors. The Division views
transactions in the context of their economic substance, rather than form.
Securities
Bulletin,
Fall 1983.